Thank you for the reply, but I still think there was something wrong with Cain’s question, because Cain DID know where Abel was, because Cain had killed him. So his question must have been inherently evil because he replied to God in a question to mask his knowledge of where Abel was. If he had not been lying he would/could have said, “I don’t know” and not add the question about “am I my brother’s keeper”. Cain was lying so the question was designed to distance himself from the truth, which is lying and evil.
Jenny
========
Hi Jenny.
I think we will agree if I explain myself more carefully.
If Cain had been righteous and was wondering one day about God’s order, he might have asked God in innocent prayer, “Am I my brother’s keeper, or is he my keeper?” So, you see, there would be no sin in that question. That is what I meant when I said that there was nothing wrong with the question itself. The wrong was in Cain’s heart, who was using an otherwise be an innocent question to hide the fact that he had sinned. ALL the wrong was in Cain; none of it was in the question he asked. And the wrong that was in Cain’s heart is what transformed the question into a lie. As I understood your reply, that is what you were saying, too.
Thanks again for the response. I hope what I am saying is clearer now.
Pastor John
Tell us what you think:
https://x.com/WitnessofSpirit/status/1863963466773479699